Mexican Grilled Chicken – My New Fav Sandwich!


For more great Instant Pot recipes, please visit InstantPotEasy.com

My buddy Judd McCutchen called me one day and said, “Man, I have a recipe you need to try and make a video with that recipe.

45 replies
  1. Dancedad7
    Dancedad7 says:

    Dude! I have been an evangelist for a while now. I have made many of the recipes (just the way you do it) and everyone I serve is BLOWN AWAY! This is by far the best chicken sandwich I have ever had. We already have a cabinet dedicated to Cholula and Meat Church, so this was easy. I also agree with everything Mrs. Meat Church tells you, but she is indeed wrong on this. I did the thigh meat and the breast meat. That will never happen again. I always go for white meat with fried chicken, but this sandwich will never be made at my house with anything but the boneless, skinless thighs. I share your site and recipes with everyone, and give your rubs out as gifts. On tap this Fathers Day weekend… The Cheerwine (I live in North Carolina) pulled pork (Cherry pellets on the Traeger) with homemade slaw on Saturday, and salmon with the maple-butter glaze on Sunday. By the way, I have five Meat Church retailers within five miles of me, so life is good!

    Reply
  2. Chris
    Chris says:

    I like how you didn’t want to get your dirty glove on your vac sealer but you got cutting board chicken juice all over the bag you put inside. Chickeny check yourself before you wreck yourself because E. coli diarrhea is bad for your health.

    Reply
  3. J B
    J B says:

    Just ran out of dia de la fajita seasoning can I substitute with regular fajita seasoning until my next bottle arrives or will the taste be way off

    Reply
  4. John & Liz Adventures
    John & Liz Adventures says:

    Made these sandwiches last night and they were spot on. I used leftovers tonight to make chopped chicken/cheese sandwiches and they were a step up from the night before to which I will give credit to marinating for another night in the fridge. Another great recipe, thank your buddy Judd for putting you on to this one.

    Reply
  5. Scott Millikan
    Scott Millikan says:

    Made these tonight and added sweet and spicy pickles. Unbelievable chicken sandwich. Did a couple without seasoning and they were great as well. They were a big hit! Thank you!

    Reply
  6. Sean Evans
    Sean Evans says:

    I love the way no one on youtube seems to be actually consistent with raw chicken safety. 🤣
    He's got gloves, then rubs the bag all over with the gloves & the cutting board, then touches the bag without gloves, etc… And yes, I'll be trying this recipe. 🤤

    Reply
  7. kyle grate
    kyle grate says:

    I live in Ohio and never heard of Dukes. Always thought peeps in the south were full of shit. We started getting it here now and it's awesome. Only kind I buy now. Oh yeah, sammies looked amazing as well.

    Reply
  8. Uncle $hoo
    Uncle $hoo says:

    Happy Father's Day love your content. Can u do a video and or a series on what smoker, grills, and all the equipment u use I would really appreciate it and would be a great help. Thanks

    Reply
  9. DropDeadFrederick
    DropDeadFrederick says:

    I made this today in my smoker. I let the chicken thighs marinate for 24 hours, I threw the Cholula and butter into a small cast iron Dutch oven style pot (about the size of the one you used) along with a few gloves of smashed garlic (peel and all), and put all of it in the smoker too. Basted the chicken every so often with the sauce. Damn they came out awesome!

    Reply
  10. RUSTY BAKER
    RUSTY BAKER says:

    How strong is the jalapeño flavor? I love spice but I don't care for the taste of jalapeños. I have a feeling these will be too spicy for the wife so I'll also be making your Chocolate pecan cobbler for an emergency apology.

    Reply
  11. Wayne Diver
    Wayne Diver says:

    Making these for Fathers Day tomorrow. My dad, who is 80 years young, loves anything Jalapeño so, he is getting these tomorrow. Matt, thank you for everything you do! I have tried damn near everything you have done videos on and have not been disappointed once! I am in Montgomery Texas, I have friends that own the bowling center in Waxahachie, I will be visiting the store at some point in the very near future. I use all of your spices (thank God I can get them at Academy). KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK MY FRIEND!

    Reply
  12. Arnold Moreno
    Arnold Moreno says:

    First time watching a Meat Church video!! Wow!! That looks so delicious!! I like how you add the hot! I like 🔥 hot. Question…what gloves do you use? I'm interested in using those as well. Thank you! Oh! I saw you mention a Nashville Hot recipe. I subscribed and will also look at that video too! Thanks again!!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *