Chicken Pan Pie – Chicken Pot Pie in a Pan – Food Wishes


For more great Instant Pot recipes, please visit InstantPotEasy.com

Making chicken pot pie in a pan doesn’t sound all that revolutionary, and it’s not, since that’s where many people make it anyway, but since it comes out so …

46 replies
  1. thegoodgeneral
    thegoodgeneral says:

    Everytime Chef John says "around the outside," I start immediately praying he's going to say it twice more. I'm so happy he's keeping that joke going.

    Guess who's back? Back again?

    Reply
  2. Øivind
    Øivind says:

    Okay so "winner winner of your chicken dinner" appears to actually be a phrase, to my disappointment I must say!! I prefer your more impromptu puns though, and the worse the puns, the better! You are, after all, the Adolf Hitler of your chicken dinner! 😀

    Reply
  3. The sinner Jim Whitney
    The sinner Jim Whitney says:

    I’m going to make this, but with a bottom crust. I’m a HUGE fan of the crust, so I like to make a pot pie with a bottom crust like a regular pie. It’ll dirty two pans instead of one, but that’s still better than the way I usually do it. I also usually omit the peas in lieu of a little spinach and home grown and canned cut Italian flat beans, just because I don’t really think peas add a whole lot (I’m not wild about peas as a general rule) and I LOVE spinach and green beans.

    Reply
  4. Michael Grosberg
    Michael Grosberg says:

    why can't I get anything to brown as beautifully as Chef John? I'm not using nonstick, just a simple aluminum skillet, but I just couldn't get either the onion or the chicken to brown no matter how much I waited. the roux also didn't quite brown but maybe I lost my patience. And the crust for some reason managed to somehow combine inside the food processor, but that wasn't a problem. Anyway the pan is in the oven, we'll see what comes out.

    Reply
  5. BARRY MALKIN
    BARRY MALKIN says:

    A lot of people would like this savory pie hot out of the oven, but I find it delicious cold out of the refrigerator. But you can have it any way you like because, after all, you're the Sergeant Vince Korsak of the temperature of your snack attack.

    Reply
  6. Oh My
    Oh My says:

    I made this for dinner last night. The taste was absolutely delicious. It was a bit loose though and I even added more chicken & veggies than called for. I did allow it to reduce for well over 5 minutes as well…hmmm🤔

    Reply
  7. The Humble Peach
    The Humble Peach says:

    I’m making this right now, it’s in the oven, though my pie butter crust didn’t turn out in one piece because I don’t have a food processor and my pie crust making skills suck 😂 I’m sure it’ll taste delicious regardless, cuz that filling alone was divine when I taste tested it

    Reply
  8. TexaSurvival
    TexaSurvival says:

    “Michael had chicken pot pie for lunch. Actually let me rephrase that, Michael had an entire chicken pot pie for lunch– Let me be more specific. Michael ate an entire, family-sized chicken pot pie for lunch and then he promptly fell asleep so we're all trying to be very quiet so as to not wake him up before 5pm.”

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *